Users, permissions, and processes / Stage 3 of 13 · step 7 of 8

Wrong file permissions

~15 min

Not running Starting usually ~20 s

Situation

The app service was moved to a new server, and it will not start. The service runs as the appuser account: on start it reads the config /etc/app/app.conf and the key /etc/app/secret.key, and it writes its log to the directory /var/lib/app.

sudo systemctl status app shows what happened to the service: the end of its output holds the last lines of its log (without sudo they are hidden). To restart it, run sudo systemctl restart app.

Task

Make it so that:

the app service works — it starts without any access denials;
appuser can read its config /etc/app/app.conf;
the directory /var/lib/app belongs to appuser, and appuser can write to it;
the key /etc/app/secret.key is accessible to appuser alone: owner appuser, mode 600.

The tools you need are already installed. There's no internet on this machine.

Lab goals

0 of 6

appuser can read /etc/app/app.conf — not checked yet
/var/lib/app is owned by appuser — not checked yet
appuser can write to /var/lib/app — not checked yet
/etc/app/secret.key has mode 600 — not checked yet
appuser can read secret.key — not checked yet
The app service is active — not checked yet

Hints

0 of 3 open · they open one at a time

Hint 1

Show the solution after 3 failed checks

Users and permissions · picked for this lab

chmod / chown — permissions and ownership

Cheat sheet

$_ — insert into the terminal

chmod 644 file rw-r--r--
chmod 755 script rwxr-xr-x
chmod 600 secret owner only
chmod 2770 team-dir setgid: new files inherit the directory's group
chown user:group file owner and group
chown -R www-data:www-data /var/www/site recursive (typical for a web root)
chgrp devs file change only the group
umask current mask for new files

Below are the main flags of chmod and chown; the full list is in man chmod/man chown.

chmod

Two syntaxes:

bash

# numeric (r=4 w=2 x=1)
chmod 644 file                    # rw-r--r--
chmod 755 script                  # rwxr-xr-x
chmod 600 ~/.ssh/id_ed25519       # private key — owner only

# symbolic
chmod u+x script.sh               # +x for the owner
chmod go-w file                   # remove write for group and others
chmod a+r file                    # read for everyone
chmod -R u+rwX dir                # recursive; X = x only for dirs/already-executable files

Capital X is handy recursively: it sets x on directories but not on every file.

chown

bash

chown alice file                  # change the owner
chown alice:devs file             # owner and group
chown :devs file                  # group only
chown -R www-data:www-data /var/www/site   # recursive (typical for a web root)
chown --reference=good.txt bad.txt # copy the owner from another file

chgrp

chgrp is the same as chown :group, but shorter and more explicit about intent:

bash

chgrp devs file                   # change a file's group
chgrp -R devs dir                 # recursive
chgrp --reference=good.txt bad.txt # copy the group from another file

umask

umask is a mask whose bits the kernel clears from the default permissions when creating a file (usually 666) or a directory (777). The full story, including where the mask comes from, is in umask. It does not touch existing files — only what gets created after it is set.

bash

umask                             # show the current mask (usually 0022)
umask 022                         # files 644, directories 755 — typical for a user
umask 002                         # files 664, directories 775 — for a shared group
echo "umask 027" >> ~/.bashrc     # make it permanent (for interactive sessions)

022 removes write for group and others; 002 removes it only for others (handy when several people share a group). For system services, set the mask in the unit (UMask= in systemd), not in ~/.bashrc, which they never read.

chmod 777 "just in case"

Almost always wrong and dangerous (especially on directories/web roots). 777 opens write access to everyone, including unrelated users on the system. Pick the minimum you need: files 644, scripts 755, secrets 600.

A shared directory for a team is not 1777

1777 (sticky bit, world-writable) is the mode for public directories like /tmp: anyone can write, but only the owner of a file can delete it (the sticky bit). It is not protection for a team directory: any other user on the system can still create files in it. For a directory owned by one group, use 2770 plus group ownership:

bash

chown :devs team-dir
chmod 2770 team-dir               # rwxrws--- : devs only, setgid

Setgid (2) makes new files in the directory inherit its group instead of the primary group of whoever created them — the team does not lose access to what colleagues create. To stop colleagues deleting each other's files, add sticky: chmod 3770. More in Special permission bits.

Recursion broke executability

chmod -R 644 dir strips x from directories → you can no longer enter them. Use u+rwX, or split it: find dir -type d -exec chmod 755 {} + and -type f -exec chmod 644 {} +.

Changed the owner — the service stopped reading the files

Many daemons run as their own user (www-data, postgres). File ownership must match the service's user.

`chmod -R` / `chown -R` on system directories

Recursively changing /, /etc, or /usr (say, trying to "fix permissions" with one command) changes the permissions of thousands of files at once, including ones whose permissions are critical to booting: sshd refuses to read a host key with the wrong permissions, sudo stops working if its own binary has the wrong permissions. Recovery means reinstalling packages (dpkg --verify, apt install --reinstall) or restoring from a backup — there is no quick way back. Scope the command explicitly (chmod -R … /var/www/site, not chmod -R … /).

`chmod 600 ~/.ssh/id_ed25519`, but not the other way around

SSH refuses to use a private key that is readable by the group or others. But chmod -R 600 on all of ~/.ssh strips x from the .ssh directory itself (if applied to it too) — then you cannot enter it at all. Directory and file permissions differ: 700 for the directory, 600 for the key files.

Wrong file permissions

Situation

Task

Signing in is needed to start the machine

chmod

chown

chgrp

umask

chmod 777 "just in case"

A shared directory for a team is not 1777

Recursion broke executability

Changed the owner — the service stopped reading the files

chmod -R / chown -R on system directories

chmod 600 ~/.ssh/id_ed25519, but not the other way around

`chmod -R` / `chown -R` on system directories

`chmod 600 ~/.ssh/id_ed25519`, but not the other way around